How to cast The Da Vinci Code without pissing me off

And now for some completely useless information...

OK. I admit that I was one of the millions of people sitting on a beach chair last summer reading the Da Vinci Code. I felt like such a conformist because that book was literally everywhere on the beach last summer. But, hey, I'm no snob. I'll read or watch any book or movie, good or bad on vacation. After I got over the title -- because he should be referred to as "Leonardo", not "Da Vinci" for Christ's sake and thus the book should have been called the "Leonardo Code" (maybe I am a bit of a snob) -- I actually enjoyed the book a lot. It really was an entertaining thriller with some interesting historical shtuff that I never cared to know about, but found utterly fascinating.

So since I was hooked this summer, the title of this Blogcritics entry piqued my curiousity. Drew Feinberg's wife Jen wrote a hilarious response to a Toronto Star article, "Da Vinci Code: Don't Blow It!", which I don't have access to. Jen's article, "How to cast The Da Vinci Code without pissing me off.", gives the Da Vinci Code reader's opinions of who should and should definitely not be cast in the roles for the movie whis is to be directed by Ron Howard. The commentary in the blog entry and the comments is pretty funny. I agree with a lot of her choices. Here's mine.

The idea of doing armchair casting for this movie is sort of fun. We did something like this at my office once, trying to cast all the people who would play us in "IIS (that's the name of my org), The Movie". For the Da Vinci Code, I agree with the commentor that says they shouldn't cast any icons with character baggage, with the exception of perhaps the Jaques Sauniere character. When I read the book, I didn't have particular people in mind to play movie roles, but I did have images in mind. And here's who seems to fit.

Robert Langdon: Hard role to fit. I like Russell Crowe, but I have a really hard time seeing him in this role. He could do it, no doubt, but I want someone a bit less macho. I can't say who the image is in my mind, but it's someone with less star power. Someone more anonymous, who's a bit average looking, tweedy yet handsome. I don't know who that is, but it's not the Toms, George Clooney or anyone like that.

Sophie Neveu: I think Juliette Binoche might have been great for this role a few years ago. Rachel Weisz fits the bill for me now. She's got the perfect look and is a solid actress. The role here is strong, very smart and ultra sophisticated (given her character's upbringing). I don't buy many of the other suggestions people have made. Kate Winslet is perhaps my favorite actress in her age group, but I don't think she's right. For some reason, I see a lot of temperance in this role and I see Kate as a passion player. Natasha McElhone is interesting but she's too damned glamorous to be a cop, even if she's supposed to be some smart code cracker. Come to think of it, that sophistication might work for her. Of utmost importance is that the chemistry between Langdon and Neveu is there. I can't really see Crowe opposite Weisz.

Note: Someone suggested Emamanuelle Bért in the comments and I have to agree that she may be be perfect as Sophie. With brown hair, rather than blonde. I also just saw The World Is Not Enough with Sophie Marceau after reading so many people recommending her and now agree that she's a contender. She's incredible in that movie, but I wonder if she's a tiny bit mature/sophisticated for the part. I'm tending to see Sophie as someone who is on the younger side, but old enough to have been through graduate school and PhD programs. Someone in her late 30s. I like the idea of Bért more and more as I compare her to the others.

Captain Bezu Fache: Jean Reno does seem perfect, Tchéky Karyo is also a compelling choice (you have to have seen La Femme Nikita to appreciate him in the role.)

Silas: I agree with William Fichter. I can't buy Paul Bettany as this villian, though he's physically right. Theres a certain kind of pathos that you see in an actors eye's that says they can play that role. Fichter has it.

Sir Leigh Teabing: Agree with Jim Broadbent. He's perfect. He looks the part and can physically portray the frail, intellectual aristocrat.

Jacques Sauniere: Yes, Sir Anthony Hopkins is perfect with or without a French accent.

Oh, and drew's blog-o-rama is awesome. It's now my favorite movie blog.

UPDATE: The point is moot now. Feels ridiculous rehashing the details of a fluffy, unimportant Hollywood flick, but here goes.

I wasn't so cracked up about Tom Hanks' hairdo as everyone else seemed to be. At least we guessed Jean Reno correctly. Everyone else was right about Paul Bettany being in it, but I was right about him feeling not creepy enough. Ian McKellen was brilliant as Teabing. I like Audrey Tatou, so she could do no harm.

Everything else about the movie was underwhelming as expected. The CGI was totally unnecessary. The flashing symbol effects used on Beautiful Mind were absolutely distracting and useless in the cryptography parts in the Louvre. Stupid. Seriously, just let the acting tell the story. This was supposed to feel like an edge of your seat thriller. No real suspense here. Any Grisham I've seen flick beat out this one by a mile.

Comments

01 Soldano
11/29/04 @ 08:16

Robert Langdon

I would love to see Kevin Kline take this role, his physique and age is ideal to be cast as a Langdon. Kline has a great screen presence with a great ability to be emotive and quirky where need be. After seeing Life as a House, I believe this man can do anything. My original thoughts of James Spader still loom because he strikes me as the academic type with a quirkiness about him. Whoever is chosen for this role it will have to be carefully chosen for longevity as I feel Langdon's adventures are akin to the Indiana Jones trilogy. Tom Hanks has been given this role purely for bankability purposes. I'm totally Hankst out...Hollywood has already sold out on the book and I'm sure the screen play will be played with in a sappy way which will be contrary to the novel..not the first time this has happened.

Sophie Neveu

Sophie has to be a total babe, the point of placing a french actor serves no purpose as all the dialogue is in english albiet with a french accent, Emmanuelle Beart is a great pick and I could quite easily envisage her as a Sophie along with Monica Bellucci or with Nicole Kidman. As mentioned in TDC, Sophie is in her early to mid 30's so all these ladies i feel could pull it off.

Leigh Teabing

An actor of great stature and screen presence has to take on this role. Sean Connery comes to mind here and also Donald Sutherland but I also like John Hurt and feel he would be best for the role. These guys are all amazing in anything the do.

Remy

Remy can be played by a relative unknown I feel and it would be totally O.K. Gary Oldman would be great here and would love to see him in this flick but the only part I feel he could be given and take ownership of it, is the roll of the Swiss Armoured Bank Depository Manager. I think he could make a memorable scene out of this character, granted it's not a huge part but none the less he could leave his mark of genius on the role and I'm stumped as to what other role to place him in.

Saunière

It's a small role here unless the movie makers choose to depict the flashbacks. I feel Francois Berleand would be perfect in this role. French, Scholastic and a degree of meekness in him would fit the role of Saunière perfectly.

Collet

This role can be played by any actor...but Adrian Paul is perfect. The films needs some eye-candy for the ladies which thus far is sorely missing. The typical fat, ugly cop sterotype which has been bounced about, like Dennis Franz or ape faced Jimmy Smits are just wrong and have no french(y) qualities whatsoever to add to the role.

Silas

Jake Busey is my choice but Udo Kier is another choice. But here is a thought...what about the huge, impossing and most ugly Ron Pearlman.

Bezu Fache

Perfect-
I see only two names: Jean Reno and Tchéky Karyo
Jean Reno has the eyes of Fache in that he can look at you and you wouldn't know what to do. And Karyo really has the bulk of a bull and can be frigntening too. Just remember him in Kiss of The Dragon what a frightening character he was there.

Bishop Aringarosa

Only one person fits this role...it HAS to be Alfred Molina Benicio Del Toro could happily play this role and be in keeping with the novel

Summary:

Langdon - Kevin Kline
Neveu - Emmanuelle Beart, Monica Bellucci, Nicole Kidman
Teabing - John Hurt, Sean Connery, Donald Sutherland
Remy - Anyone
Swiss Armoured Bank Depository Manager: Gary Oldman
Saunière - Francois Berleand
Collet - Adrian Paul
Silas - Ron Pearlman,Udo Kier, Jake Busy
Bezu Fache - Either Jean Reno or Tchéky Karyo
Aringarosa - Alfred Molina, Benicio Del Toro

The production costs of this movie would render it unprofitable so could not be made with all these stellar actors but hey anyone can dream....lol

02 jibbajabba
11/29/04 @ 09:03

Wow.

Emamanuelle Bért maybe be perfect as Sophie. With brown hair, rather than blonde. I also just saw The World Is Not Enough with Sophie Marceau after reading so many people recommending her. She's a contender. She's incredible in that movie, but I think she's a tiny bit mature and too sophisticated for the part. I like the idea of Bért more and more as I compare her to the others.

Kevin Kline is interesting. Still holds some star baggage for me though. I want someone less prominent, but a solid actor like Kline.

And Gary Oldman as the Swiss Bank Depository manager is genius. A small, but very cool role.

Advertisement
03 Nick
11/29/04 @ 14:23

I read it and I can only see Langdon: William H. Macy
And we all know who is going to play Sophie Neveu. Hint: Initials A.J.
Her father could play Jacques Sauniere

04 jibbajabba
11/29/04 @ 16:29

Angelina is an interesting choice too. I just saw her in Life or Something Like It (2002) for the first time and really liked her performance in that. I don't know about Jon Voight, though. I really like him, but I sort of agree with Jen, that Sir Anthony would be perfect.

05 Jilks
11/30/04 @ 06:03

And what about Sophie Marceau for the role of Sophie Neveu?

06 jibbajabba
12/02/04 @ 12:53

Julie Delpy is apparently talking to producers of Da Vinci Code. She might be very good as well, but I like the younger actresses we're discussing above for the role.

Why oh why are so many people talking about Tom Hanks for Langdon.

07 Anonymous
12/06/04 @ 20:02

This is a lineup I'd like to see:

Aringarosa: Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia
Teabing: Richard Attenborough
Neveu: Angelina Jolie
Langdon: Sam Neill
Remy: Simon Kunz

08 the monkey boy
12/07/04 @ 16:52

Robert Langdon -I believe Tom Hanks is totally not meant for this role and ron howard is just going with a big name. Kevin Kline would be good for this role, maybe even Dennis Quaid?

09 Anonymous
01/10/05 @ 18:09

How about Guy Pierce for Robert Langdon....a bit young, but a terrific "actor's actor." He'll play the role close to the book's character without being too macho. He can give off that scholarly, somewhat timid, yet adventurous presence for this role.

10 Soldano
01/18/05 @ 16:33

Guy Pierce, although a likeable actor and enjoyed him in Momento is not quite the robust presence that is required for this role. Unfortunately with a movie of such hype such as this an A Grade actor has to be placed to help ensure movie bankability at the box office and DVD sales.

At this point in time i'll take anyone other than Hanks for this role but it looks like a done deal unfortunately.

Regards Soldano

Advertisement
11 nayajhen
01/22/05 @ 21:34

Well, looks like Tom Hanks is the man here. Nevertheless, I am revolted by his name for that character. There is no way he could pull this off. This is one of those Indian Jones characters and must be young, charismatic, a bit bookish and must be able to pull of a coat with an elbow patch :). They'll need to pick someone who can share good chemistry with Sophie Neveu.

Looks like they've chosen Audrey Tautau for Sophie. That's not too bad. Rachel Weisz was the first name in my mind but I guess that's down the drain.

Jean Reno for Bezu Fache, 'nuff said!

Sauniére must be Sir Anthony.

Sir Teabing I guess Jim Broadbent is already in the bag.

William Fichtner is playing Silas and I definitely like his presence, I think he'll do justice to the role.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <b> <strong> <dd> <dl> <dt> <i> <li> <ol> <u> <ul> <code> <blockquote> <fieldset> <legend> <h6> <span> <img> <div> <p>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • You may post code using <code>...</code> (generic) or <?php ... ?> (highlighted PHP) tags.

More information about formatting options